By Steve Carroll, Principal, BNP, Inc. ยท November 10, 2026
Introduction
In the fall, staffing cracks begin to appear. It is budget time and strategic planning time, and year-end is staring us down. For the people who carry risk and Business Continuity Management (BCM) responsibilities at a community bank or credit union, the same question comes up every year: do we reallocate resources to complete unfinished projects, or bump them to Q1 next year?
This article offers staffing guidance for that decision. It explains why BCM work is so hard to staff evenly, what regulators expect management to provide, how to decide what must be finished before year-end, and how targeted outside expertise can complement in-house resources without replacing them. Where a point comes from published guidance, it is cited. Where it comes from BNP, Inc.’s own experience supporting banks and credit unions, it is labeled Practice-based.
The uneven calendar of BCM work
Practice-based. One of the hardest staffing challenges for risk employees, especially those with BCM responsibilities, is how the work effort is distributed over the calendar year. Some months require almost no BCM effort. Other months, when the Business Impact Analysis (BIA) refresh, plan updates, testing, and board reporting all land together, BCM can take 80% of a person’s time.
That swing is hard to absorb, especially when the employee also has non-administrative production duties: a loan portfolio, an operations queue, a branch, or an IT help desk. When production and BCM compete for the same hours, production wins, because customers and members are waiting. Risk work takes a back seat.
The result is predictable. Partially completed projects get papered over, with the hope that examiners in the next cycle won’t notice. A BIA is re-dated rather than re-done. A test is held but never written up. A plan is “under review” for a second year. None of these is a deliberate decision to cut corners. Each is the natural outcome of a peak workload landing on a person whose job was never sized for the peak.
What the guidance expects
The FFIEC is direct that staffing the BCM program is a board and management responsibility, not something left to whoever has spare time.
- Resources are a governance duty. The FFIEC lists “Allocating resources to BCM activities” among the elements of BCM governance, and expects the board to oversee the program “by allocating adequate resources to business continuity” (FFIEC BCM Booklet, 2019, Section II.A).
- Management must provide people, not just budget. Management oversight should include “Allocating knowledgeable personnel” and sufficient financial resources (FFIEC BCM Booklet, 2019, Section II.A).
- Roles and succession must be defined. Management oversight should include “Defining BCM roles, responsibilities, and succession plans,” and the board should be “Assigning BCM responsibility and accountability” (FFIEC BCM Booklet, 2019, Section II.A).
- People can be a single point of failure. In the BIA, “Personnel can be a single point of failure if there are no cross-trained personnel to back up their responsibilities” (FFIEC BCM Booklet, 2019, Section III.A). That is as true of the BCM coordinator as of anyone in operations.
- Examiners ask about staffing changes. The examination procedures direct examiners to identify changes that could affect resilience, including “Loss, addition, or change in duties of key personnel” (FFIEC BCM Booklet, 2019, Appendix A, Objective 1).
- The work must be current, and provably so. The BIA methodology “should be repeatable, allowing management to reevaluate information after significant changes” (FFIEC BCM Booklet, 2019, Section III.A), and BCM documentation “should include evidence substantiating periodic updates of the BIA, risk assessment, and BCP(s)” (FFIEC BCM Booklet, 2019, Section VIII).
The guidance does not say every institution needs a full-time BCM coordinator. It does say that the program needs knowledgeable people, enough of their time, and a backup when they are not available. How an institution meets that expectation is a staffing decision, and outside expertise is one legitimate way to meet it.
Does any of this sound familiar?
Practice-based. These three situations come up every fall. Each is a staffing problem first and a BCM problem second.
Situation 1: The newly minted BCM coordinator
The bank has a newly minted BCM coordinator, who now has to learn the job while they crank out the reports for this year.
- What is at risk: A new coordinator under deadline pressure tends to copy last year’s documents forward. The reports get produced, but the BIA is not really refreshed, and the coordinator never learns why the numbers are what they are. The FFIEC’s expectation of “knowledgeable personnel” is met on paper only.
- Where targeted help fits: An experienced facilitator runs this year’s BIA sessions with the coordinator in the room, then hands over progressively: the consultant leads the first departments, the coordinator co-leads the middle ones, and the coordinator leads the last ones with the consultant as backup. This year’s deliverables get done, and next year the coordinator owns the process.
Situation 2: The GRC database nobody has touched
The GRC database hasn’t been touched for two years, and it was a mess back then. Meanwhile, you’ve had a core conversion and a new Loan Origination System.
- What is at risk: The BIA still lists retired systems as critical resources, the new core and LOS are missing or only partly mapped, and recovery time objectives were set for platforms that no longer exist. Every report drawn from the database inherits those errors. This is exactly the “significant change” that the FFIEC expects a repeatable BIA to absorb.
- Where targeted help fits: A scoped data cleanup inside the GRC tool you already own. Reconcile resources against the current system inventory, retire the old core and its dependencies, map the new core and LOS to the business functions that use them, and confirm recovery objectives with IT and the vendors. Start with the most critical functions so that, if the work is split across year-end, what is finished first is what matters most.
Situation 3: Hiring, with an exam 45 days out
You’re trying to hire a BCM coordinator. The search is under way, and you have two prospects with BCM experience, but not in banks. The next examination is scheduled in 45 days.
- What is at risk: Two separate gaps. In the short term, nobody owns exam preparation, and the evidence of periodic updates the FFIEC expects may be scattered or missing. In the longer term, a strong BCM professional from another industry may not yet know the FFIEC booklet, examiner expectations, or how banking functions and core processors fit together.
- Where targeted help fits: Interim support now, onboarding support later. In the next 45 days, assemble the evidence package, close the gaps that can honestly be closed, and document a dated plan for the ones that cannot. After the hire, a short period of banking-specific orientation and side-by-side work turns a good BCM generalist into a bank BCM coordinator faster than learning alone.
Practice-based. In the 45-day situation, resist the urge to paper over. A clear, dated remediation plan with a named owner tells an examiner that management knows where the program stands. A document that claims to be current when it is not tells them something else.
Finish now, or move it to Q1?
Practice-based. Not everything has to be finished by December 31. The decision is easier when it is made item by item rather than all at once. The table below is a starting point, not a rule.
| Work item | Lean toward finishing now | Reasonable to move to Q1 |
|---|---|---|
| BIA for critical functions | A major system, vendor, or organizational change has happened since the last BIA | No material change, and the prior BIA is less than a year old |
| BIA for lower-tier functions | An examiner flagged it in the last cycle | No change and no open finding |
| Test or exercise write-up | The test is done but undocumented; memories fade fast | The test itself is scheduled for Q1 |
| GRC database cleanup | Reports drawn from it go to the board or examiners this cycle | Cleanup of low-criticality records only |
| Plan updates | Contacts, vendors, or recovery sites have changed | Formatting or structural improvements |
Whichever way an item goes, write the decision down. Record what was deferred, why, who owns it, and the target date, and make sure the BCM committee or the board knows. A documented deferral is a management decision. An undocumented one looks like an oversight.
What targeted outside help looks like
Practice-based. Outsourcing BCM does not have to mean handing over the program. For most community banks and credit unions, the best fit is strategic, targeted assistance with four characteristics.
- It is scoped to the gap. Help with the peak, not the whole year: a BIA cycle, a database cleanup, exam preparation, or a coordinator transition. The in-house team keeps ownership of the program.
- It works inside your existing tools. The work should land in the GRC database and reporting you already use, not in a consultant’s spreadsheets that leave when the engagement ends. Clean data in your own system is what lasts.
- It builds your people. Every engagement should leave the internal coordinator more capable, through side-by-side facilitation, documented procedures, and a clean handoff. That is how “knowledgeable personnel” becomes a fact rather than a title.
- It is sized to management’s authority. A targeted engagement can often be priced within management’s existing spending authority, so it can start now rather than wait for the next board cycle. The board still oversees the program and its resourcing, and management should report the engagement through normal BCM reporting.
Like any service provider, an outside consultant is a third party. Include the engagement in your third-party risk management process, and keep the access to confidential information proportionate to the work.
A fall staffing checklist
Practice-based. Before budgets are final, BCM owners and their managers can work through these questions.
- Map the calendar. List every BCM deliverable for the next twelve months by month, and estimate the hours each needs. Where are the peaks?
- Compare peaks to capacity. For each peak month, how many hours does the coordinator actually have after production duties?
- Name the backup. If the coordinator left tomorrow, who would run the next BIA session or answer an examiner’s question?
- Check the database against reality. Have there been core, LOS, vendor, or organizational changes since the last full BIA? If so, has the GRC data caught up?
- Sort open work into “now” and “Q1.” Use a table like the one above, and document every deferral.
- Decide where outside help fits. Target it at the peaks and gaps, inside your existing tools, with knowledge transfer built in.
- Budget for it now. A modest line item for peak-season support is easier to approve in October than an urgent request in the week before an exam.
Conclusion
BCM work does not arrive evenly, and the people who do it at community banks and credit unions usually have other jobs too. The FFIEC expects knowledgeable personnel, adequate resources, defined succession, and documentation that proves the work is current. When the fall crunch makes that hard, the answer is not to paper over unfinished work. It is to decide deliberately what gets finished now, document what moves to Q1, and bring in targeted help where the calendar and the staff do not line up.
Sources
- Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council, FFIEC IT Examination Handbook: Business Continuity Management, November 2019, Sections II.A, III.A, VIII, and Appendix A. Announced in FDIC FIL-71-2019.
Statements marked Practice-based reflect BNP, Inc.’s experience supporting banks and credit unions and are not drawn from the source above.
